官术网_书友最值得收藏!

第37章 34

Men will frequently fall into fallacies through not setting out the terms of the premiss well, e.g. suppose A to be health, B disease, C man. It is true to say that A cannot belong to any B (for health belongs to no disease) and again that B belongs to every C (for every man is capable of disease). It would seem to follow that health cannot belong to any man. The reason for this is that the terms are not set out well in the statement, since if the things which are in the conditions are substituted, no syllogism can be made, e.g. if 'healthy' is substituted for 'health' and 'diseased' for 'disease'.

For it is not true to say that being healthy cannot belong to one who is diseased. But unless this is assumed no conclusion results, save in respect of possibility: but such a conclusion is not impossible: for it is possible that health should belong to no man.

Again the fallacy may occur in a similar way in the middle figure: 'it is not possible that health should belong to any disease, but it is possible that health should belong to every man, consequently it is not possible that disease should belong to any man'. In the third figure the fallacy results in reference to possibility. For health and diseae and knowledge and ignorance, and in general contraries, may possibly belong to the same thing, but cannot belong to one another.

This is not in agreement with what was said before: for we stated that when several things could belong to the same thing, they could belong to one another.

It is evident then that in all these cases the fallacy arises from the setting out of the terms: for if the things that are in the conditions are substituted, no fallacy arises. It is clear then that in such premisses what possesses the condition ought always to be substituted for the condition and taken as the term.

主站蜘蛛池模板: 富平县| 休宁县| 新兴县| 新建县| 文化| 富源县| 遵义县| 达州市| 海安县| 潼关县| 宁陵县| 遵化市| 合山市| 清河县| 蓬莱市| 大化| 丹江口市| 永登县| 浦江县| 沙洋县| 台湾省| 富裕县| 辰溪县| 化州市| 潜江市| 屯昌县| 天水市| 永昌县| 全州县| 瑞安市| 长武县| 会东县| 马鞍山市| 青冈县| 威宁| 镇沅| 涪陵区| 浮山县| 和田市| 兴宁市| 若羌县|